Though it is never said aloud at any point in the movie, Mary’s Joon suffers from a mental health illness, and is potentially schizophrenic. Many critics have zeroed in on the aforementioned disease as Joon would often talk to herself, or to someone she felt was there. She could hear ‘voices in her head’ and had auditory hallucinations. Benny is shown to be her sole guardian as their parents died in an accident. The two share a meaningful and sweet sibling bond until that gets somewhat frayed by the charming Sam’s entry, who is apparently homeless and has a penchant for physical comedy. But when Sam and Joon fall in love, Benny throws Sam out of their lives. The rest of the storyline takes off from there.
Let’s talk about the said ‘blunder’ first before we get to the good part. As in the case of several earlier features, Benny and Joon doesn’t exactly get mental health illness right. While its depiction of schizophrenia was decent, as Mary would indeed talk to herself, throw fits and refuse to take her daily medication sometimes; it was still not what it could have been. The movie shows her as someone who is able to control her own life to some degree, especially after she gets smitten with Depp’s character. She doesn’t seem to have very many bad days and is able to lead on an okay-ish life. That is not the case with most patients. In Benny and Joon, you get a clean version of what it is to be like, or to be around, a schizophrenic patient. Granted, the times were different and you can only show so much in films, but still, a little more detail and some better writing, with respect to Joon’s character, could not have hurt.
Hollywood Rewind: Crimson Peak | The Holiday | My Blueberry Nights | The Help | Mission Impossible | Chef | Revolutionary Road | I’m Not There | Donnie Brasco | Sicario | Edge of Tomorrow | Spy Kids | 1998’s Godzilla | The Others | Phone Booth | Wild | Scream | The Godfather Part II | One Fine Day | True Romance | Little Women | Face-off | Pulp Fiction | Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon | The Age of Innocence | Mean Girls | Die Hard | Never Been Kissed | Citizen Kane | Kill Bill Volume I | Terminator 2 Judgment Day | Titanic | Heat | Home Alone | Jerry Maguire | Brief Encounter | The Truman Show | The Deer Hunter | The Shining | Clueless | Ferris Bueller’s Day Off | Blue Velvet | Taxi Driver | The Lord of the Rings I | Zero Dark Thirty | The Godfather | Say Anything | Warm Bodies | Bright Star | Malcolm X | Stardust | Red Eye | Notting Hill | Fargo | The Virgin Suicides | The Breakfast Club | Enchanted | Walk the Line | Blood Diamond | Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban | Mortal Kombat | Bridges of Madison County | Edward Scissorhands | Breakfast at Tiffany’s | She’s Gotta Have It | Ever After | The Devil Wears Prada | The Matrix | Creed | Mulan | Ratatouille | Shutter Island | Her | Dead Poets Society | Sleepless in Seattle | Waitress | Pride and Prejudice | The Dark Knight | Before Sunset | School of Rock | About a Boy | A Few Good Men | 50/50 | Begin Again | Brooklyn | Drive | Chocolat | Batman Begins | 10 Things I Hate About You | The Departed | Freedom Writers | Pretty Woman | Dan in Real Life | Jurassic Park | Tangled | Meet Joe Black | Monster’s Ball | Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind | You’ve Got Mail | Half Nelson | Fight Club | Doubt | American Psycho | Julie and Julia | Forrest Gump | The Silence of the Lambs | Finding Neverland | Roman Holiday| American History X | Tropic Thunder | Before Sunrise | Scent of a Woman | Finding Forrester | Sixteen Candles
That said, the film does have some fine performances. Mary Stuart did the best she could with the given material. You believed her pain, of having to live in a dependent fashion with her older sibling, and the suffering she undergoes when Sam is taken from her. Aidan fit the part of the caring, mature brother to the T. Meanwhile, Johnny Depp was a complete scene stealer. You couldn’t help but look at him in every frame he occupied, so you get what Joon could have felt. Depp’s Sam had an innocent but magnetic way about him. A personal favourite sequence has to be the one in the diner, when inspired by the likes of Charlie Chaplin and Buster Keaton, Sam makes the rolls dance. In fact, all the three lead stars seemed to share a great chemistry. It would be stone-hearted not to root for them and their individual happy endings, which (SPOILER), they ultimately get.
You can watch Benny and Joon on Google Play.